CAPE-based Calculator
A withdrawal rate set from the cyclically-adjusted earnings yield, the inverse of Shiller’s CAPE ratio, so the rate falls when stocks are expensive.
Part of the FIRE simulator, a historical backtest calculator that replays your plan across every rolling window of market history. Backtests use US market data from 1871 through 2025.
How CAPE-based did in US market history
CAPE-based cannot run out of money at its standard settings, because it withdraws a share of what is left each year; over 116 start years of US market history from 1881, the first year this rule has the data it needs, through 2025, on the simulator’s default plan ($1,000,000 in 80% stocks, 15% bonds and 5% cash, over 30 years, before fees and taxes, rebalanced yearly), its spending after inflation fell as low as $23,000 in 1995, 60% of what the retirement that began in 1966 spent in its first year. Its first withdrawal ranged from $35,964 to $115,156, depending on the start year. Over the same 116 start years, Constant Amount, which takes $40,000 (4% of the portfolio) in the first year and raises it with inflation, ran out in 2 (the retirements that began in 1966 and 1969). The worst start year was 1966, the retirement that paid out the least in total after inflation.
How the CAPE-based strategy works
The CAPE-based rule sets each year’s withdrawal rate to a base of 1.75% plus 0.5 times the cyclically adjusted earnings yield, which is 100 divided by Shiller’s CAPE ratio, and withdraws that rate of the current balance. At a CAPE of 25 the yield is 4% and the rate is 3.75%; at a CAPE of 40 the yield is 2.5% and the rate is 3%.
A high CAPE, meaning expensive stocks, lowers the rate and a low one raises it, so the rule spends less when the market is expensive and more when it is cheap. Because the withdrawal is a share of the current balance, it also moves with the portfolio every year.
Where the CAPE-based strategy comes from
Karsten Jeske set the rule out in August 2017, in part 18 of the safe withdrawal rate series on his Early Retirement Now blog, writing the withdrawal rate as an intercept plus a multiple of the cyclically adjusted earnings yield. One example the article charts uses an intercept of 1.75% and a multiple of 0.5.
- Jeske, K. (2017). The Ultimate Guide to Safe Withdrawal Rates – Part 18: Flexibility and the Mechanics of CAPE-Based Rules. Early Retirement Now, 30 August 2017.
- Shiller, R. J.. US stock price, earnings and dividends, and interest rates, monthly since 1871. shillerdata.com, the data used in Irrational Exuberance (Princeton University Press).
What the CAPE-based strategy trades off
Setting the rate from the cyclically-adjusted earnings yield ties spending to how expensive stocks are each year, the signal that foreshadows a bad sequence. It cuts withdrawals during a boom, when a cut is hardest to accept, and the result depends on CAPE data and the chosen coefficients.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Responds to valuation-driven sequence-of-returns risk
- Spends more when markets are cheap
- Grounded in the widely-cited Shiller CAPE research
Cons
- Depends on CAPE data and the chosen coefficients
- Can feel counterintuitive to cut spending in a boom
- Valuation timing is imperfect
Parameters you can adjust
- Base withdrawal rate (a): The fixed floor of the rate formula (rate = a + b × CAPE earnings yield), in percentage points. It sets the baseline withdrawal rate before valuations adjust it.
- CAPE earnings-yield weight (b): How strongly cheap markets raise the withdrawal rate. The rate is a + b × the CAPE earnings yield (100 ÷ CAPE), so a higher b lets valuations move spending more.
Questions about the CAPE-based strategy
What does Shiller’s CAPE have to do with withdrawals?
CAPE, the cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio Robert Shiller popularised, compares stock prices with ten years of inflation-adjusted earnings. This rule turns it into an earnings yield, 100 divided by CAPE, and lets that yield set part of each year’s withdrawal rate.
How is the CAPE-based rule different from the 4% rule?
The 4% rule fixes the first year’s amount and raises it with inflation. The CAPE-based rule recomputes a rate every year from valuations, 1.75% plus 0.5 times the earnings yield by default, and applies it to the current balance, so income responds to both prices and the portfolio.
When does the CAPE-based rule cut spending?
When valuations rise or the portfolio falls. A rising CAPE lowers the earnings yield and with it the rate, so the rule cuts spending during a boom as well as after a crash.
Backtest CAPE-based against market history
Opens the simulator with CAPE-based already selected, so you only set your portfolio and horizon.