Vanguard Dynamic Spending Calculator

A percent-of-portfolio target with a ceiling and a floor on how far spending can move from one year to the next.

Part of the FIRE simulator, a historical backtest calculator that replays your plan across every rolling window of market history. Backtests use US market data from 1871 through 2025.

How Vanguard Dynamic Spending did in US market history

Vanguard Dynamic Spending ran out of money in 0 of 126 start years of US market history from 1871 through 2025, on the simulator’s default plan: $1,000,000 in 80% stocks, 15% bonds and 5% cash, over 30 years, before fees and taxes, rebalanced yearly. Its first withdrawal was $50,000. Over the same 126 start years, Constant Amount, which takes $40,000 (4% of the portfolio) in the first year and raises it with inflation, ran out in 2 (the retirements that began in 1966 and 1969). Its leanest year came in 1958, in the retirement that began in 1929: $14,300 after inflation, 29% of that retirement’s first year. The worst start year was 1969, the retirement that paid out the least in total after inflation.

How the Vanguard Dynamic Spending strategy works

Vanguard Dynamic Spending withdraws 5% of the portfolio in year one, then each year recomputes 5% of the current balance and limits the change from last year’s withdrawal to at most 5% higher and at most 2.5% lower, by default. A target inside that band is withdrawn as it stands; one outside it stops at the ceiling or the floor.

The target supplies most of the responsiveness of a percentage rule and the band supplies the year-to-year stability of a fixed amount. Vanguard applies the band to spending in real terms; this calculator applies it to nominal amounts, so inflation shifts the real limits slightly.

Where the Vanguard Dynamic Spending strategy comes from

Vanguard researchers Colleen M. Jaconetti, Francis M. Kinniry, Michael DiJoseph and Zoe B. Odenwalder described the rule in a September 2016 Vanguard research paper and summarised it in January 2017 in the journal of the American Association of Individual Investors (AAII). Their example caps a year’s rise in spending after inflation at 5% and its fall at 2.5%.

  1. Jaconetti, C. M., Kinniry, F. M., DiJoseph, M., and Odenwalder, Z. B. (2017). Vanguard’s Dynamic Spending Strategy for Retirees. AAII Journal (American Association of Individual Investors), January 2017, adapted from the authors’ September 2016 Vanguard research paper "From Assets to Income: A Goals-Based Approach to Retirement Spending".

What the Vanguard Dynamic Spending strategy trades off

Capping the year-to-year change keeps spending tied to the portfolio without letting it swing: both the rise and the fall are bounded and known in advance. In a deep downturn the floor can outpace the portfolio, and in a strong market the ceiling trims the upside.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Balances responsiveness with income stability
  • Bounded, predictable year-to-year changes
  • Set out in published Vanguard research

Cons

  • The floor can outpace the portfolio in deep downturns
  • Caps trim upside in strong markets
  • Three inputs to tune (target, ceiling, floor)

Parameters you can adjust

  • Target portfolio percent: The percent-of-portfolio spending target before the ceiling and floor below limit how much it can change year to year.
  • Ceiling (max yearly increase): The most spending can rise from one year to the next, as a percent of last year. Caps upside jumps in strong markets.
  • Floor (max yearly decrease): The most spending can fall from one year to the next, as a percent of last year. Limits painful cuts after a bad year.

Questions about the Vanguard Dynamic Spending strategy

What is Vanguard’s dynamic spending rule?

A percent-of-portfolio withdrawal with a ceiling and a floor on how much spending can change from one year to the next. Vanguard’s researchers used a 5% ceiling and a 2.5% floor; this calculator defaults to 5% and 2.5% on a 5% target.

How is Vanguard Dynamic Spending different from the 4% rule?

Vanguard’s researchers place the two on one range. A fixed inflation-adjusted amount is the dynamic rule with a 0% ceiling and a 0% floor, and a pure percentage of the portfolio is the rule with no limits at all. The dynamic rule sits between them.

When does Vanguard Dynamic Spending cut spending?

When the target falls below last year’s withdrawal. The cut is the smaller of the gap and 2.5%, so a crash lowers spending by at most 2.5% a year in nominal terms, and through a long downturn the floor keeps withdrawing more than the target would.

Backtest Vanguard Dynamic Spending against market history

Opens the simulator with Vanguard Dynamic Spending already selected, so you only set your portfolio and horizon.

Run the Vanguard Dynamic Spending simulation