Sensible Withdrawals Calculator

A low base percentage every year, plus a slice of any real gains the portfolio has made above its starting value.

Part of the FIRE simulator, a historical backtest calculator that replays your plan across every rolling window of market history. Backtests use US market data from 1871 through 2025.

How Sensible Withdrawals did in US market history

Sensible Withdrawals cannot run out of money at its standard settings, because it withdraws a share of what is left each year; over 126 start years of US market history from 1871 through 2025, on the simulator’s default plan ($1,000,000 in 80% stocks, 15% bonds and 5% cash, over 30 years, before fees and taxes, rebalanced yearly), its spending after inflation fell as low as $14,800 in 1982, 49% of what the retirement that began in 1966 spent in its first year. Its first withdrawal was $30,000. Over the same 126 start years, Constant Amount, which takes $40,000 (4% of the portfolio) in the first year and raises it with inflation, ran out in 2 (the retirements that began in 1966 and 1969). The worst start year was 1966, the retirement that paid out the least in total after inflation.

How the Sensible Withdrawals strategy works

Sensible Withdrawals takes 3% of the current balance every year, plus 10% of any amount by which the balance exceeds the starting portfolio grown with inflation, by default. In years when the portfolio is at or below its inflation-adjusted start, the base is the whole withdrawal.

The base is a small share of whatever the balance is, so it falls with the portfolio and nothing holds the balance at its starting value; the extras pay out only on real gains, when markets do well. Because the extras depend on gains, the part of the income above the base cannot be known a year ahead.

Where the Sensible Withdrawals strategy comes from

Sensible Withdrawals is a generic base-plus-bonus rule. No published primary source for it is cited on this page.

What the Sensible Withdrawals strategy trades off

A low base withdrawal keeps spending a small share of the balance, and a slice of the real gains above the inflation-adjusted start pays out when markets do well. The base alone is lean in flat years, and the bonus half of the income cannot be budgeted a year ahead.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Low base withdrawal draws the portfolio down slowly
  • Shares in market gains without over-committing
  • Conservative base keeps the plan resilient

Cons

  • The base alone may feel lean in flat markets
  • Bonus income is unpredictable
  • Two rates to configure

Parameters you can adjust

  • Base withdrawal rate: The share of the portfolio always withdrawn, even in flat or down years.
  • Bonus rate on real gains: The share of real gains above the inflation-adjusted starting amount, taken as extra spending in good years.

Questions about the Sensible Withdrawals strategy

How is Sensible Withdrawals different from the 4% rule?

The 4% rule pays a fixed amount raised with inflation. Sensible Withdrawals pays 3% of the current balance plus 10% of any real gains by default, so its income follows the portfolio instead of staying level.

What counts as a gain in Sensible Withdrawals?

Only growth beyond the starting portfolio raised with inflation. A balance that has kept pace with inflation and no more has no gains, and pays the base alone.

When does Sensible Withdrawals cut spending?

Whenever the balance falls. The base falls with it, and the bonus shrinks or disappears as the real gains do.

Backtest Sensible Withdrawals against market history

Opens the simulator with Sensible Withdrawals already selected, so you only set your portfolio and horizon.

Run the Sensible Withdrawals simulation